|
24 of 29 people found the following review helpful: By This review is from: Dungeon Master's Guide: Core Rulebook II v. 3.5 (Dungeons & Dragons d20 System) (Hardcover) Well when they did 3.5 I would have thought that is was a fill in on the holes in 3.0. It is not. Most things have the basics from 3.0 but many things are totaly different from the ground up. If you want to do 3.5, you have to do all the books. This is not a partial switch, it is an all or nothing. When you first switch you keep finding more changes that on first look make no sense. After playing 4 or 5 sessions, you start to realize that , hey this is really good. My first impression was that 3.5 was the pitts, but after a good while, I realized it is much better than 3.0. I started playing d&d in 1977, and this is a really nice version, once you realize that it is a new total rework, not just a half step. If you are going to switch and need to get all three books, by them as the set. The price drop for the set makes it much easer on the money. 23 of 28 people found the following review helpful: By Lockarm "Lockarm" (Cherry Hill, NJ United States) - See all my reviews This review is from: Dungeon Master's Guide: Core Rulebook II v. 3.5 (Dungeons & Dragons d20 System) (Hardcover) I was among the most vehemently obstinate when it came time to make the decision to convert to the 3rd Edition Dungeons and Dragons. I've been playing using the first and second edition rules sets for nearly 15 years, and my first read-through of the 3e core rules made me think about only one thing - Magic: The Gathering.However, my group and I have recently seen the light and moved into the realm of Third Edition, and I will admit that I was very wrong to cast it aside so quickly. Streamlined rules, simplified spell descriptions, combat rounds that don't seem to stand still - I could go on an on. But this review is about the Dungeon Master's Guide, and I have but one word - OUTSTANDING. One of the fatal flaws of the second edition DMG was its apparently convenient "parallel organization" - that is, the chapters were organized in the same order in both books to make reference easier. However, the 3e DMG has done away with this, and for good reason - most of the...Read more 18 of 22 people found the following review helpful: By This review is from: Dungeon Master's Guide: Core Rulebook II v. 3.5 (Dungeons & Dragons d20 System) (Hardcover) Even if you refuse to pick up the 3.5 PHB, I seriously recommend getting the 3.5 DMG, for these reasons.1) More prestige classes. The ones in the old 3.0 were subpar; the new ones added are great, even through they should have left out the Red Wizard one if they insist on it being a Forgotten Realms only class. 2) You want to have extra-planar or epic level adventures. Well, you can buy the new DMG and skip buying the Manual of the Planes and Epic Handbooks, as the core stuff in both books is in the new DMG as well. However, you probably don't want to use the Epic system used here, as without the Epic Book's spell seeds, spellcasters are rather subpar. The new DMg is basically the old DMG with all the best stuff from the past 3 years included. A must buy for any DM, even if you have the old 3e DMG, especially for the ... price. |