Customer Reviews
Average Customer Review
(13 customer reviews) 15 of 15 people found the following review helpful
Space Adventure or American History?,
September 3, 2011 G. Peter Wityk "Peter Wityk" - See all my reviews
This review is from: Into the Hinterlands (The Citizen) (Hardcover)
This book is set as an adventure in the distant future and is both readable and enjoyable as such. I see echos of Daniel Leary in Allen Allenson. I see details of writing and plotting that remind me of John Lambshead's Lucy's Blades. There is action, adventure and battle to suit the tastes of those who want that in a book. It's done with typical Drake panache and verve along with the fine English touch of Lambshead. Read it and enjoy it for that.
However, there is more here. The life and times of Allen Allenson remind me of nothing so much as the life and times of George Washington through a comparable period i.e. through the French and Indian wars. Case in point -
1. Allenson leads a survey party in the first section of the book.
2. Allenson is a gentleman and son of a gentleman. His father and mother are both dead. His stepmother and he do not get along. He was raised by an older half-brother who was Inspector General of the planetary militia...Read more
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful
disappointing battle scenes,
September 11, 2011 This review is from: Into the Hinterlands (The Citizen) (Hardcover)
Thanks to Peter Wityk for his remarks about the analogy to George Washington in the book. That was very insightful. Unlike some reviewers who just paraphrase the plot, Wityk clearly stood back and took a more analytic and broader view.
In the current book there is often amusing repartee. A conversational back and forth depicting a future space faring society, with a social structure analogous to a European country of the 19th century or earlier. Hence many remarks about a prevasive class structure and a peon or servant underclass. The book refers to the heroes as being from a Brasilian entity. Yet there are few [none?] Portuguese names. Where is the connection to our Brazil other than the name? It sounds like a simpleminded effort to introduce a superficial air of exoticism. There is no mention of how we went from current Brazil to that Brasil, and this can be a continual nagging point to some readers.
Now the mode of space travel is largely via bicycle-type...Read more
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
Not a good read,
January 10, 2012 Joseph B. Moore "Joe" (Ga) - See all my reviews
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Into the Hinterlands (The Citizen) (Hardcover)
I have read many of David Drakes books and enjoyed most of them.
This will not be my favorite of his books. Plot develops too slow and not enough action at the beginning.
A slow read.
Joe